| Year | Champion | Runner-Up | Score | Most Outstanding Bowler |
| 2023 | Mercyhurst | Molloy | 2-0 Trad: 1044-971 Baker Total: 1052-899 |
TBA |
| 2022 | Wilmington | Adelphi | 2-0 Trad: 1091-992 Baker Total: 1099-1023 |
Rachel Hirst, WILMU |
| 2021 | Roberts Wesleyan | Daemen | 2-1 Trad: 816-967 Baker Total: 959-911 Baker Best-of-7: 4-3 |
Kayla Kawyn, RWC |
| 2020 * | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a |
| 2019 | Caldwell | Lincoln Memorial | 4-1 | Jenna Rapach, CALD |
| 2018 | Lincoln Memorial | Franklin Pierce | 4-1 | Marisol Dodson, LMU |
| 2017 | Adelphi | Lincoln Memorial | 4-1 | Katelyn LaRocca, ADE |
| 2016 | Adelphi | Kutztown | 4-1 | Rebecca Gotterbarn, ADE |
* - 2020 championship canceled due to COVID-19 pandemic
** - Format of final changed to megamatch beginning in 2021 season
