| Year | Men's Champion | Women's Champion |
| 2023 | Roberts Wesleyan | Roberts Wesleyan |
| 2022 | St. Thomas Aquinas | Roberts Wesleyan |
| 2021 | Roberts Wesleyan | Roberts Wesleyan |
| 2020^ | n/a | n/a |
| 2019 | St. Thomas Aquinas | Roberts Wesleyan |
| 2018 | St. Thomas Aquinas | Roberts Wesleyan |
| 2017 | St. Thomas Aquinas | Roberts Wesleyan |
| 2016 | Roberts Wesleyan | Roberts Wesleyan |
| 2015 | Roberts Wesleyan | Roberts Wesleyan |
| 2014 | Queens | Dist. Columbia |
| 2013 | Queens/St. Thomas Aquinas | Georgian Court |
| 2004 | C.W. Post | C.W. Post |
| 2003 | NYIT | NYIT |
* The conference did not sponsor a championship from 2005-2012
^ - 2020 championship canceled due to COVID-19 pandemic
