| Year | Champion | Runner-Up | Score | Most Outstanding Player |
| 2023 | St. Thomas Aquinas | Molloy | 8-3 | Carissa Della Vecchia, STAC |
| 2022 | Bridgeport | Molloy | 2-0 | Kaite Burawski, UB |
| 2021% | Bridgeport | St. Thomas Aquinas | GM1: 3-2 GM2: 5-4 |
Kaite Burawski, UB |
| 2020# | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a |
| 2019 | Bridgeport | LIU Post | 3-0 | Amanda Staheli, UB |
| 2018 | LIU Post | Molloy | 4-1 | Abbey Fortin, LIUP |
| 2017 | Mercy | LIU Post | 7-0 | McKaily Cusumano, MER |
| 2016 | Molloy | LIU Post | 4-0 | Tracey Balinskas/Milan Botte, MOL |
| 2015 | Queens | LIU Post | 2-0 | Monique Roberge, QC |
| 2014 | LIU Post | Molloy | 16-7 | Aly Dzierzynski/Nicole Hagenah, LIUP |
| 2013 | Molloy | LIU Post | 4-1 | Megan Butterworth, MOL |
| 2012 | Molloy | Dowling | 6-0 | Haley Calderwood/Kelley Jansen, MOL |
| 2011 | Molloy | Dowling | 4-0 | Megan Butterworth, MOL |
| 2010 | Dowling | Molloy | 3-0 | Jessie Stavola, DOW |
| 2009 | C.W. Post | NYIT | n/a * | Sara Kiser, CWP |
| 2008 | C.W. Post | Adelphi | 2-1 | Samantha Yodowitz, CWP |
| 2007 | Dowling | C.W. Post | 10-0 | Jaqueline Lucido, DOW |
| 2006 | C.W. Post | Queens | 8-0 | Samantha Yodowitz, CWP |
| 2005 | Dowling | C.W. Post | 1-0 | n/a |
| 2004 | C.W. Post | New Haven | 9-2 | n/a |
| 2003 | C.W. Post | Queens | 4-3 | n/a |
| 2002 | C.W. Post | Adelphi | 6-2 | n/a |
| 2001 | Queens | Adelphi | 2-1 | n/a |
| 2000 | C.W. Post | Adelphi | 9-1 | n/a |
| 1999 | Queens | Molloy | 11-0 | n/a |
| 1998 | C.W. Post | Adelphi | 2-1 | n/a |
| 1997 | Adelphi | C.W. Post | 8-2 | n/a |
| 1996 | Dowling | C.W. Post | 6-3 (12 inn.) | n/a |
| 1995 | Molloy | Saint Rose | 5-3 | n/a |
| 1994 | C.W. Post | Molloy | 13-1 | n/a |
| 1993 | C.W. Post | n/a | n/a $ | n/a |
| 1992 | Southampton | Saint Rose | 6-1 | n/a |
| 1991 | Southampton | Concordia | 8-1 | n/a |
| 1990 | Concordia | Southampton | 2-1 | n/a |
$ - no championship was held in 1993
* - 2009 Championship was not completed due to rain
# - 2020 season canceled due to COVID-19 pandemic
% - 2021 Championship decided by best-of-three series
