| Year | Champion | Runner-Up | Score | Most Outstanding Player |
| 2023 | St. Thomas Aquinas | Daemen | 72-66 | DeVante Jamison, STAC |
| 2022 | St. Thomas Aquinas | Daemen | 59-48 | Demetre Roberts, STAC |
| 2021 | St. Thomas Aquinas | Daemen | 83-67 | Grant Singleton, STAC |
| 2020 | St. Thomas Aquinas | Bridgeport | 74-67 | Osbel Caraballo, STAC |
| 2019 | Molloy | Bridgeport | 90-86 (OT) | Nick Corbett, MOL |
| 2018 | St. Thomas Aquinas | Bridgeport | 82-65 | Justin Reyes, STAC |
| 2017 | St. Thomas Aquinas | Molloy | 97-86 (OT) | Charlie Marquardt, MOL |
| 2016 | St. Thomas Aquinas | Daemen | 80-63 | Chaz Watler, STAC |
| 2015 | Bridgeport | St. Thomas Aquinas | 82-78 | Willie Williams III, UB |
| 2014 | Bridgeport | St. Thomas Aquinas | 94-73 | JoJo Swift, UB |
| 2013 | Bridgeport | Dowling | 61-53 | JoJo Swift, UB |
| 2012 | C.W. Post | Bridgeport | 86-67 | Stefan Bonneau, CWP |
| 2011 | C.W. Post | Bridgeport | 68-64 | Stefan Bonneau, CWP |
| 2010 | Bridgeport | C.W. Post | 70-61 | Steve Martin, UB |
| 2009 | C.W. Post | Bridgeport | 62-56 | Nick Carter, CWP |
| 2008 | C.W. Post | Adelphi | 60-57 | Jonathan Schmidt, CWP |
| 2007 | Adelphi | C.W. Post | 61-58 | Kimani Blaze, ADE |
| 2006 | Adelphi | Bridgeport | 74-62 | Kimani Blaze, ADE |
| 2005 | Queens | Philadelphia | 82-74 | John Sikiric, QC |
| 2004 | C.W. Post | Philadelphia | 77-65 | Gerry McNair, CWP |
| 2003 | Adelphi | C.W. Post | 70-57 | Wayne Nelson, ADE |
| 2002 | Queens | NYIT | 80-63 | Phil Lyons, QC |
| 2001 | Adelphi | Philadelphia | 94-78 | Ryan McCormack, ADE |
| 2000 | St. Rose | Molloy | 90-72 | Nate Connolly, STR |
| 1999 | Adelphi | St. Rose | 75-73 (OT) | Yaacov Williams, ADE |
| 1998 | St. Rose | Adelphi | 75-70 | Damon Reed, STR |
| 1997 | St. Rose | Adelphi | 84-64 | Ralph Bucci, STR |
| 1996 | Adelphi | St. Rose | 77-76 | Danny Gimpel, ADE |
| 1995 | St. Rose | Adelphi | 90-68 | Garth Joseph, STR |
| 1994 | Philadelphia | C.W. Post | 56-54 | n/a |
| 1993 | Philadelphia | St. Rose | 85-75 | n/a |
| 1992 | Philadelphia | St. Rose | 79-66 | n/a |
| 1991 | C.W. Post | Dowling | 70-68 | Jason Waters, CWP |
| 1990 | C.W. Post | Dowling | 91-76 | Jimmy Feagins, CWP |