Year | Champion | Runner-Up | Score | Most Outstanding Player |
2023 | Queens | Molloy | 9-8 (10 inn.) | Anthony Fontana, QC |
2022 | Molloy | Queens | 12-10 | Peter Theodorellis, MOL |
2021 % | Molloy | St. Thomas Aquinas | GM1: 4-3 GM2: 2-1 |
Charlie Cucchiara, MOL |
2020 * | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a |
2019 | LIU Post | Bridgeport | 15-0 | Giovanni Ciaccio, LIUP |
2018 | St. Thomas Aquinas | Molloy | 3-2 | Nicholas Lucchese, STAC |
2017 | LIU Post | Molloy | 9-7 | Noah Lorenzo, LIUP |
2016 | Dowling | Bridgeport | 3-2 | Tim Going, DOW |
2015 | St. Thomas Aquinas | Bridgeport | 4-1 | Anthony Morris, STAC |
2014 | St. Thomas Aquinas | Dowling | 4-3 (10 inn.) | Derek Hirsch, STAC |
2013 | St. Thomas Aquinas | Bridgeport | 9-1 | Kenny Kirshner, STAC |
2012 | Dowling | Bridgeport | 7-0 | Tyler Badamo, DOW |
2011 | Dowling | Bridgeport | 1-0 | Brian Ferguson, DOW |
2010 | C.W. Post | Molloy | 6-5 (11 inn.) | Mike Callaghan, CWP |
2009 | Adelphi | Dowling | 11-0 | n/a |
2008 | C.W. Post | New Haven | 5-1 | Brian Anderson, CWP |
2007 | Adelphi | C.W. Post | 7-6 | Ryan Boelsen, ADE |
2006 | Dowling | New Haven | 9-2 | Kevin Reese, DOW |
2005 | Dowling | Adelphi | 7-5 | Tim Nese, DOW |
2004 | New Haven | Dowling | 14-5 | n/a |
2003 | Dowling | St. Thomas Aquinas | 11-4 | n/a |
2002 | Concordia | Dowling | 7-3 | n/a |
2001 | Molloy | Dowling | 12-2 | n/a |
2000 | Concordia | Dowling | 10-9 | n/a |
1999 | Concordia | Adelphi | 4-1 | n/a |
1998 | Queens | Dowling | 12-4 | n/a |
1997 | Adelphi | Saint Rose | 12-3 | n/a |
1996 | Adelphi | Queens | 8-2 | n/a |
1995 | Saint Rose | Adelphi | 9-4 | n/a |
1994 | Adelphi | Saint Rose | 10-2 | n/a |
1993 | Adelphi | Saint Rose | 15-8 | n/a |
1992 | Saint Rose | Adelphi | 16-10 | n/a |
1991 | Dowling | Adelphi | 5-2 | n/a |
* - 2020 season canceled due to COVID-19 pandemic
% - 2021 Championship decided by best-of-three series